Aura Kasih
For discerning iPhone users, the decision of which Apple audio accessory to acquire, whether for initial adoption or replacement of a seasoned model, often hinges on an appreciation for the seamless integration and exclusive functionalities that Apple products deliver. The company has meticulously cultivated a suite of features, ranging from synchronized audio sharing and effortless device switching across the Apple ecosystem to real-time language translation and enhanced Apple TV connectivity, many of which are optimized to function exclusively, or at their peak, with Apple’s proprietary hardware and software.
Currently, the AirPods lineup presents a diverse array of four distinct models, each engineered to cater to specific user needs and preferences. The fundamental distinction begins with the form factor: in-ear earbuds versus over-ear headphones. For those seeking the immersive experience of over-ear headphones, the AirPods Max stands as the singular, premium offering. Within the earbud category, Apple provides three compelling options: the advanced AirPods Pro 3, the feature-rich AirPods 4 with Active Noise Cancellation, and the foundational AirPods 4.
Rigorous Evaluation: Our Methodology for Assessing AirPods
The selection of the optimal AirPods model is informed by an extensive and multi-faceted testing protocol. Our evaluation process involves dedicating significant time, often spanning dozens of hours for initial reviews and continuing for weeks and months thereafter, to thoroughly assess each product’s performance. This prolonged usage period allows for a comprehensive examination of critical aspects such as audio fidelity, microphone clarity for communication, and overall device reliability.
When evaluating noise cancellation capabilities, we expose the AirPods to a wide spectrum of auditory environments, from bustling urban settings to the comparative quietude of an office. The hearing protection features of the AirPods Pro have been rigorously tested in high-volume settings, such as live concerts, to ascertain their efficacy. Furthermore, a substantial portion of our assessment focuses on the synergistic benefits derived from the integration of AirPods with other Apple devices, meticulously examining the seamless interplay and enhanced user experiences.
The Pinnacle of Personal Audio: AirPods Pro 3
The third-generation AirPods Pro represent a significant evolution in Apple’s true wireless earbud offering, presenting a compelling case for the best overall audio solution within the ecosystem. This iteration introduces substantial improvements over its predecessors, most notably in the realm of fit and comfort. The redesigned chassis boasts a more refined, angular aesthetic, complemented by an expanded range of ear tip sizes, including an additional XXS option. This meticulous attention to detail in fit addresses a common user concern, ensuring a more secure and comfortable experience for a broader spectrum of ear anatomies. The innovative "foam-infused" ear tips, a hybrid of foam and silicone, offer a unique advantage by subtly expanding to create a superior seal and enhanced passive noise isolation, a crucial factor for both audio quality and active noise cancellation effectiveness. For individuals who have previously experienced issues with AirPods dislodging, the enhanced fit of the Pro 3 is a primary consideration.
Beyond the physical enhancements, the AirPods Pro 3 deliver notable advancements in noise cancellation technology, bringing them into direct competition with the premium AirPods Max. These earbuds exhibit a marked improvement in their ability to attenuate high-frequency sounds, such as ambient conversations, and effectively neutralize low-frequency drones, such as those produced by aircraft engines, surpassing the performance of previous AirPods Pro generations. The sonic reproduction has also undergone significant refinement, with discernible enhancements in bass punch, vocal clarity, and the revelation of subtle nuances within musical compositions. Battery longevity is another area of strength, with the Pro 3 capable of sustaining operation for a full workday with Active Noise Cancellation engaged before requiring a recharge from their case.
Further augmenting their utility, the AirPods Pro 3 incorporate the recently introduced clinical-grade hearing aid functionality, empowering users with advanced auditory assistance. The inclusion of a heart rate sensor further expands their capabilities, enabling direct workout tracking through the earbuds. Coupled with robust IP57 water and dust resistance, fortified Find My features, and an intuitive live translation capability, the AirPods Pro 3 unequivocally establish themselves as Apple’s premier wireless earbuds, offering a comprehensive and sophisticated audio experience.
An Alternative for Unencumbered Listening: AirPods 4
For a segment of users who find the sensation of in-ear tips restrictive or uncomfortable, Apple offers the AirPods 4 as a compelling alternative. This model eschews the sealed-ear-tip design in favor of a more open acoustic architecture, ensuring users remain aware of their surroundings. While the AirPods Pro’s transparency mode is highly effective, the AirPods 4 inherently provide this ambient awareness without the need for active processing.
Apple currently offers two distinct configurations of the AirPods 4. Regardless of the chosen variant, users can expect consistent sound quality, reliable microphone performance for voice calls, and an IP54 rating for water and dust resistance. The more premium AirPods 4 model introduces desirable features such as Active Noise Cancellation and an upgraded charging case that supports Find My integration and wireless charging. The active noise cancellation on this open-design model is surprisingly effective at reducing general ambient noise and low-frequency hums, though it is important to note that louder sounds and direct speech will inevitably penetrate due to the less sealed acoustic design.
Individuals prioritizing superior noise isolation and immersive audio are strongly advised to consider the AirPods Pro 3. However, for those with a firm preference against ear tips, the noise-canceling AirPods 4 present a viable option, albeit with acknowledged limitations in ANC performance compared to their sealed-ear-tip counterparts.
The Premium Headphone Experience: AirPods Max
For enthusiasts of over-ear headphones, the AirPods Max represent Apple’s flagship offering, delivering a premium audio experience. While their initial release was met with some debate regarding their considerable price point and weight, subsequent updates and a focus on specific user benefits have solidified their position. The meticulously crafted design, featuring acoustically engineered earcups and a mesh canopy, prioritizes comfort for extended listening sessions, particularly in warmer environments where traditional pleather earcups can lead to discomfort.
The noise cancellation capabilities of the AirPods Max are exceptional, offering a profound sense of acoustic isolation. The transparency mode is particularly noteworthy for its natural and clear reproduction of ambient sound, surpassing that of many competing high-end headphones. In terms of audio reproduction, the AirPods Max deliver a pleasing sonic profile that demonstrates versatility across a broad spectrum of musical genres. Their expansive soundstage for a closed-back headphone design allows for an immersive listening experience.
While the AirPods Max utilize Apple’s older H1 chip, resulting in the absence of certain adaptive audio features found in newer earbuds, they compensate with a distinct advantage in audio fidelity. The recent integration of lossless audio support via USB-C significantly elevates their audio quality, positioning them as the apex of sonic reproduction within Apple’s entire audio product portfolio. This feature caters to audiophiles who prioritize the highest possible fidelity in their listening experience.
The Horizon of Apple Audio Innovation
With the recent conclusion of Apple’s autumnal hardware showcases, the current AirPods lineup appears to be in a state of relative stability. Apple’s product release cycles for its entry-level AirPods do not follow an annual cadence, and the AirPods Pro 3 have only recently entered the market. The AirPods Max, since their debut in 2020, have seen only incremental updates, such as the introduction of USB-C connectivity and new color options in 2024.
Speculation suggests a future trajectory for AirPods that may involve the integration of camera technology and enhanced support for Apple Intelligence features. Previous industry reporting has hinted at such developments, indicating a potential for AirPods to evolve into more intelligent and interactive personal audio devices. However, the timeline for such advancements remains uncertain, and widespread adoption is not anticipated in the immediate future. The current generation represents a mature and well-defined offering, catering to a broad range of user needs within the Apple ecosystem.
Ayu Aulia
Ridwan Kamil
Safa Marwah
Lisa Mariana